Coaly's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[At Your Funeral - Collab]

It was a poor collab

As far as collabs go it wasn't very good, the animation looked very rushed, whether it was or not. The graphics were generally below average. When there was animation it was alright but there wasn't very much. Please put more effort, more thought, and more time into your collab next time. I was dissapointed to see this. It wasn't horrible it just seemed less than it could have been.

icarus responds:

I dont totally agree, but thanks anyway.

[Mask]

I'm in heaven

Really, it was all beautiful. the sketchiness was slightly offsetting, but the amazing animation made up for it. The fighting was well animated, and the bird, it was fun to see all the shapes you used to draw the flash. The style suited it because it was a dream, and that is the way dreams are, sketchy. The guy was fighting himself, nice touch.

[Just A Bad Day]

yeah ok

*caught*

the wtf is reversed when you flip the graphic

...its midly funny but pay attention to detail, i dont want to hear this "2 days" crap, you could at least draw some decent feet. The animation is a little slow and choppy, use 24 fps please, i think you were on 12 but im not sure, or use 20 at least. Not bad.

Trippy-Hippie responds:

yeah im on 12 FPS.To tell you the truth im a bit afraid to move up, but o well. Im experiemnting with it.
The feet and the graphics are supossed to be simple and all "basic shaped" but yeah whatever.
Animation DOES need lots of work, and yes... you caught me... The WTF flipped, but that was a flaw that happened when the whole body was flipped in the "image controls" or whatever.

[Fox's Day]

amazing

Your are a creative genious, your screen play is inspiring. While the graphics were lacking and sometimes the forms were off it was put together very well. You used the song very nicely. I don't know why it was a fox, besides that your friend is called that, but the running fox was done nicely, especialy when he is jumping through the ruble. Please try to fill in all the color even if it is time consuming because it will be worth it and appreciated. Once again, very good job.

ZombieLincoln responds:

Thank you for the review - I'm beflattered =D

Right, my friend would rather be drawn as an anthropomorphic fox than as himself. Good enough reason for me!

You're right about the color - I was sloppy and there's no excuse. I...I'm so sorry...

[All NG Fads Die!!! 4!!!]

um, sweet

Topz you straight up owned the life out of all of them...that guy's movement is beautiful. Why don't you have any other movies out? That game was freaking lame. This was definately alot better than the other ones even though some things got redone. That is alot of people you turned down...good job.

MACception responds:

Yeah, Topz is quite the leader of us all. With hopes of following awesomeness, I'll be rotoscoping most of my animations in the near future. It just looks so clean and good. We'll see what happens. Glad you liked some of it man.

-LP
www.LogoPresents.com/AFD

[Legend of Zelda - TP]

mmm, stylish

more interactivity would have been better, but it could have stood as a movie in itself. The graphics and effects were stylish.

[FbF Jam Session]

oh man

Personally I do hate fbf's. This one was nice, the guy's animation was smooth and well drawn. Everything else looked cool but it's jsut fbf. Does it not bother anyone else that this kind of stuff gets 3.5? I mean it was good but not brilliant, or anything someone hasn't done before.

PROXER responds:

I think that whatever people enjoy should get high ratings, weither it's been done a few times or not.

[FBF CF 4!]

sigh

I said it before and I will say it again, fbf like this is easy and sucks ass. This is content from the otherscombined you know... Oh yeah and in the other reiew of mine you asked me if i could do it again, and yes i could do it again, and much better. You did this in what, a day. Draw things, make up a story, animate the things you drew to make the story. And like i said before, this will get through but it is lame, and overdone.

theY4Kman responds:

If it can get through with a 2.90 rating, how does it suck ass???

[FBF 2: Sequel]

stop the fbf

It may get through the portal, but it is lame and has been done infinite times. Make something worth watching with actual animation.

theY4Kman responds:

Well, as people are different, I like FBF...You did a good job at your flash, but can you do it again? I can do this so many times because I'm good at it! But thanks for the criticism. I know there are too many FBF's out there...

[nuGuy Episode 6]

nice

Limbs would be nice too though. Also, after being shot through the head, the girl still blinks.

maconefilms responds:

Yeah... I will pay more attention to that in the next movie...